Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

Discover Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant & Connie's Ice Cream in Erie, PA, offering delicious wings, pizza, subs, and irresistible ice cream cones, milkshakes, and chocolates. Perfect for family dining and sweet cravings!

Welcome to Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

Taste the Difference.

Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

Experience the best of Italian comfort food at Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant, where the aroma of pizzas blends with delightful ice cream treats. Located at 3150 W 32nd St in Erie, PA, this family-friendly spot specializes in mouthwatering pizzas, crunchy subs, and creamy Parsons like the famous Black Raspberry and Praline. Whether you crave crispy wings or a feast of appetizers, this restaurant has it all, making it a go-to for locals and visitors alike. With a casual vibe, Presque Isle Pizza ensures that every meal feels like a community gathering, perfect for enjoying with family and friends.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

3150 W 32nd St, Erie, PA 16506, United States

Phone

+1 814-838-1008

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream
Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant stands out in Erie, PA with a menu designed to bring comfort and satisfy cravings. This Italian restaurant offers something for everyone, whether it's pizza, subs, or refreshing ice cream. Specifically focusing on fresh ingredients, the kitchen takes pride in hand-crafted dishes that echo traditional recipes while adding a local twist. On the pizza front, options like the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Nitemare tantalize with bold flavors and generous toppings.

Subs are equally impressive; from classic Ham and Cheese to creative combinations, each one bursts with its unique taste.

The commitment to quality extends to the desserts offered in the adjacent Connie's Ice Cream parlor. Here, flavors like chocolate and the local favorite black raspberry make for a perfect summer treat. Moreover, the restaurant frequently engages the community through events, special promotions, and collaborations with local suppliers, supporting Erie’s own economy.

Patrons not only enjoy diving into delicious food but also contribute to a vibrant local scene.

For families, it’s a haven—those with kids find that the restaurant caters to younger appetites with tailored menus and generous portions. Moreover, with an average price point of approximately $10.02, dining out becomes an affordable luxury. The staff embodies warmth and welcoming spirit, making every visit feel personal and special. Regulars often return not just for the food, but for the bonds that form within these walls.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday3-8 PM
  • Thursday3-8 PM
  • Friday3-8 PM
  • Saturday3-8 PM

Dine in or grab a quick bite—Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant offers both convenience and quality. The menu boasts a diverse range of dishes including 41 delightful options, from hearty pizzas topped with fresh ingredients to tasty subs that satisfy every craving. For those looking to share, try the Antipasto salad loaded with flavors or the ranges of deep-fried munchies perfect for snacking. If you have a sweet tooth, the ice cream selection will not disappoint, providing delightful cones and shakes. The average price for a satisfying meal is $10.02, making this spot budget-friendly. With a commitment to taste and texture, every bite promises to be better than the last. Plus, the ambiance is warm, inviting, and conducive to memorable meals.

Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream

The exterior of Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant exudes a casual charm that invites all. Set against the backdrop of Erie, PA, the restaurant's simple yet welcoming facade makes it hard to resist. Bright signage signifies the delicious food awaiting inside. The outdoor seating offers an enjoyable spot for patrons to bask in the sun while savoring their meals. Families often find that sharing a pizza outside, with laughter filling the air, creates the perfect dining experience. The friendly vibe enhances every visit, making it a popular choice for quick lunches or relaxed dinners.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Connie's ice cream was being served at the Presque Isle Poker Run. Highlight of the event! I had apple pie flavored and my husband had pumpkin pie. Both were delicious.

J
Jan B.

Great place. My family loved the pizza and I loved the wings. The kids devoured some ice cream when it was all done. Last game of the season dinner my daughter picked was great!!! Can't wait to go back.

M
Mike D.

Very impressed! We got the family bucket and a side gluten free dish (pasta) and it was a TON of food. The meatballs are real meat yall.

S
Shannon B.

Great ice cream and it's fresh homemade!.you have to go inside to order (it was at a window a long time ago) I got a single scoop and it was really the perfect amount (snickers flavor) servers were all friendly and quick can't wait to go back!

E
Emily F.

I love the owners- always friendly and they treat you like family. Food is delicious with lots of options, best Gluten free pizza that doesn't make me feel like I am getting less than because of my allergies. Thank you Friends! We will always be repeat Customers!

V
Valerie C.

The owner was very nice and valued her customers. This place has the best homemade pizza and ice cream! We loved that they had salad options to feed our group of 7, too!

A
Alisha B.